Conventions 2000: Media Reality Check, Thursday AM Edition
1) Cheney's "Red Meat" Dissected: "I Thought This Was the Convention of Sweetness and Light." Dan Rather advised: "Consult Shakespeare, Henry the 4th, Prince Hal, the son who wanted to restore what was once his father's."
2) Party Not Tolerant Enough for NBC: "Is the Republican Party Held Hostage...By Its Views on Abortion?" asked Tom Brokaw. David Bloom demanded of J.C. Watts whether Cheney as VP sends "the wrong message to the black community?"
3) "Compassion Clashes With His Record": ABC Took on Bush on Health Insurance, Tax Cuts, Environment. Dean Reynolds: "He is the candidate who talks of making health insurance available to all who want it, but has fought to limit federal insurance for children."
Front page article. Cheney's "Red Meat" Dissected: "I Thought This Was the Convention of Sweetness and Light"
Even before Dick Cheney spoke Wednesday night, Tom Brokaw relayed the opposition's attack. On the NBC/MSNBC simulcast he announced: "Already the Gore campaign is out with a rebuttal to Dick Cheney's speech...They're saying, 'The mask is off the GOP masquerade ball. It's the most negative Republican convention speech since Pat Buchanan.'"
Afterward, Brokaw assessed: "Richard Cheney tonight, borrowing a phrase from Al Gore in 1992, 'It is time for them to go.' He proved himself an unflappable, if not a dynamic speaker tonight." Tim Russert chimed in: "You could feel this audience, they've been pent up for three days, with the politics of happiness, niceties. They wanted to let loose a little bit. And Dick Cheney gave them, if not red meat, a little steak tartar at least."
Just past 11pm on MSNBC, Jim Miklaszewski asked Wyoming Governor Jim Geringer "Was it too strongly negative?" And to Congressman Bob Livingston, he bemoaned: "But I thought this was the convention of sweetness and light. What happened to that?"
FNC's Paula Zahn complained: "There were some stinging rebukes in this speech. That one line in particular, 'Soon our men and women in uniform will once again have a Commander-in-Chief they can respect, one who under-stands their mission and restores their morale.' Ouch!"
ABC's George Stephanopoulos took up the liberal line: "I wonder whether it played as well at home. It was all about fixing the culture in Washington, not fixing the problems of the country. We'll see."
Dan Rather delivered the oddest comments: "Dick Cheney, in a metaphor that he as a former Secretary of Defense might use, delivered a...stealth bomber kind of attack in under the radar, quietly, but hitting hard at Clinton-Gore, as he so often referred to it. The themes were the themes of restoration. Restoration of what was, the son to lead the restoration of a father....If you want to read more about it you might consult Shakespeare, Henry the 4th, Prince Hal, the son who wanted to restore what was once his father's."
Top of page two story. Party Not Tolerant Enough for NBC: "Is the Republican Party Held Hostage...By Its Views on Abortion?"
Another night Wednesday of mostly questions from the left on MSNBC, with Tom Brokaw obsessed about the party's lack of tolerance, but a few questions from the right squeezed through.
David Bloom to J.C. Watts: "Why should African-Americans...be heartened by his [Cheney] nomination when he voted against the creation of the Department of Education, voted against higher funding for Head Start, voted against a ban on cop-killer bullets? Doesn't that send the wrong message to the black community?" (Bloom raised a conservative point with Dick Armey: "There's been a lot of talk about more conservative Republicans, the right wing of the party being excluded from this convention. What do you make of that?")
Tom Brokaw to Newt Gingrich: "But speaking of inclusiveness, in the platform it tolerates no other point of view except anti-abortion. There were people who tried to say that we welcome other points of view...."
Brokaw to Christine Todd Whitman: "Is the Republican Party held hostage in your judgment, Christie Whitman, by its views on abortion? So that people like you, who believe that there ought to be some choice can never be considered for Vice President?" Brokaw followed up to Pat Robertson about the platform committee: "They wanted it only in the unreconstructed view: We are against abortion, period, no other point of view will be tolerated?"
"Compassion Clashes With His Record": ABC Took on Bush on Health Insurance, Tax Cuts, Environment
In what may be a preview of the media's approach to the fall campaign, Wednesday's World News Tonight dedicated an entire story to supposed proof of how George W. Bush's "much talked about compassion clashes with his record." The evidence listed by reporter Dean Reynolds defined compassion as supporting specific liberal policy prescriptions.
Reynolds began by noting how Bush's photo-op with Hispanics "symbolizes his image as a different, more open kind of Republican." Then Reynolds pounced: "In his home state he is undeniably more popular among minorities than any other Republican, but there are times when it seems Bush's much talked about compassion clashes with his record. He is, after all, the same man who addressed the racially intolerant Bob Jones University six months ago and who refused to take a stand on the Confederate flag flying in South Carolina by repeatedly saying it was up to the people of that state to decide."
Jumping to the convention, Reynolds assumed anyone opposed to certain specific legislation -- of a liberal variety of course -- is not compassionate: "He went along with having an openly gay Congressman address the convention last night, yet Bush opposes hate crimes legislation, gay marriage and gay adoption. He is the candidate who talks of making health insurance available to all who want it, but has fought to limit federal insurance for children. Bush is the candidate who has proposed a huge tax cut as a way to help the working class." After a clip of Bush, Reynolds hit the idea from the liberal class warfare angle: "But more than sixty percent of the relief would go to the richest ten percent of Americans. And while he speaks of the need to protect the environment, Bush supports mostly voluntary efforts to do it."
"On many of these issues, the Governor offers a softer sounding position than many Republicans," Reynolds agreed before countering in conclusion: "It is the reality behind the rhetoric that may prove troublesome for him in the fall."
Fox News Channel Beat Out MSNBC: Monday Night More Tuned in to Brit Hume Than Tom Brokaw
Monday night a repeat of NBC's Third Watch beat ABC's convention coverage and CBS's 48 Hours, which showed Colin Powell's speech, but in the cable world more tuned in to the Fox News Channel (FNC) than MSNBC. That's quite a feat considering fewer homes have access to FNC, and MSNBC showcased its NBC News stars, led by Tom Brokaw and Tim Russert.
USA Today's Peter Johnson on Wednesday provided the Neilsen numbers for Monday night. Third Watch attracted 10 million viewers while 6.4 million watched 48 Hours and 5.9 million tuned in to ABC during the 10pm ET hour. The three cable news networks garnered a total of just 2.4 million viewers. CNN attracted 1.2 million, down 35 percent from the first night in 1996. FNC came in second with 676,000 viewers, ahead of MSNBC with 516,000.
Score one for FNC prime time anchors Brit Hume and Paula Zahn and FNC's decision to actually show speakers on the podium.
Sidebar articles run along the sides of pages two and three. Rather on Bush's Face; Rather on Cheney's Secret "Clinton Gore" Agenda; Rather's Special Spin; NBC Resurrected the "Little Brown One"
Rather on Bush's
Verging on incoherence, Rather intoned: "I suggest you look closely at the eyes, what some people call the triangle of the face, the eyes running down to the nose and mouth. Sometimes George W. Bush looks a little tense in there, now he's returning to that, but when he went over the top, and he's officially the party's nominee, well, it said it, along the lines of 'how good it is.'"
Well, maybe a bit beyond incoherence.
Rather on Cheney's
Secret "Clinton Gore" Agenda
After Cheney said, "We're all a little weary of the Clinton-Gore routine...it is time for them to go," Rather helpfully explained: "You may want to note that Cheney is referring to Clinton-Gore, not Clinton and Gore, in effect making Clinton Al Gore's first name: Clinton Gore."
the "Little Brown One"
NBC played old video of George H. W. Bush pointing across an airport tarmac: "That's Jebby's kids from Florida, the little brown ones."
O'Donnell then asked George P: "You were referred to as one of 'the little brown ones,' by your grandfather. That was controversial then, would it be even more so today?" George P. replied: "My grandfather is the sweetest, most loving man that I know. It was a term of endearment. And I would call my own grandkids that because there's nothing as beautiful as brown skin."
Quote of the Night: "He's a hard-right conservative, as Cokie says...What George W. Bush seems to have done is solidify his party base; that is, he's pleasing conservatives...The question will be should Bush have selected someone to reach out, with that sex appeal?" -- ABC's Sam Donaldson about Dick Cheney before he addressed the convention Wednesday night.
As a Web/e-mail
bonus, here's the quote in full:
END Reprints of Media Reality Check articles
This "Conventions 2000: Media Reality Check" compiled by me with the late night work of MRC analysts Geoffrey Dickens, Jessica Anderson, Paul Smith and Brad Wilmouth. Plus Andy Szul loading up the Web page at sunrise and Eric Pairel at sunset. In Philadelphia: Tim Graham, Liz Swasey and Joyce Garczynski. -- Brent Baker