CyberAlert -- 08/17/2001 -- Tax Cut Blamed for Shortfall
Tax Cut Blamed for Shortfall; CNN: Bill "Elvis" Clinton "The First Rock Star President"; "Conservatives Use Floggings..."
1) The Bush White House re-allocating money from Social Security to general revenue? ABC anchor Charles Gibson immediately blamed the tax cut: "They need it...because they're strapped because of the tax cut." CBS's John Roberts referred to how Democrats will blame the "huge tax cut" for "jeopardizing the surplus."
2) The "mid-August convergence" of Bill Clinton's birthday and the anniversary of when Elvis died prompted CNN's Bill Schneider to gush: "Elvis, the first rock star. Clinton, the first rock star President. It's no secret that Bill Clinton drew on Elvis for inspiration. You might say Elvis won the 1992 election for Clinton." And it grew more fawning.
3) Monday's New York Times also conveyed the same analogy: "Mr. Clinton's Southern_style charisma evokes comparisons with Elvis." The same story also praised Clinton's life story: "From humble origins in an Arkansas town called Hope to his hairsbreadth escapes from a long series of scandals culminating in impeachment, Mr. Clinton is an outsized protagonist with commensurate flaws. His story has the makings of a classic..."
4) Newsweek's Eleanor Clift held up a liberal Congressman with a solid pro-abortion voting record as "an unlikely champion for expanded stem-cell research." Clift marveled at how in California "only Gary Condit has a more conservative voting record," but her hero earned a mere 16 percent rating from the ACU.
5) The New York Times blamed "a Republican-backed law" for making it too easy for the INS to deport illegal immigrants, even those in fear for their life back home. But the law in question passed with overwhelming bi-partisan majorities in the House and Senate and was signed by President Clinton.
Corrections: The August 15 CyberAlert quoted Smith County, Texas
District Attorney Jack Skeen, in recounting the crime committed by death
row inmate Napoleon Beazley, as saying on CBS's The Early Show that he
"then came back around and shot Mr. Luttig at point black
range." Black should have read blank.
>>> Tax cut favoring and pro-life
comments from an actress repeated. On Thursday night CBS re-ran the July
16 edition of the Late Late Show with Craig Kilborn on which Patricia
Heaton, co-star of CBS's Everybody Loves Raymond sit-com, admitted that
she voted for Bush, boasts to her friends about the then-coming tax rebate
and is "pro-life." To read what she said or to watch a
RealPlayer clip of her political comments during her appearance, refer
back to the July 18 CyberAlert:
The White House announcement that it planned to re-configure revenue allocations from previous years, in order to shift $4.3 billion into general revenues so as to ensure that surplus Social Security tax revenue will not be spent, prompted ABC anchor Charles Gibson to immediately blame the tax cut for the reduced general revenue: "They need it...because they're strapped because of the tax cut."
On Thursday night CBS also jumped on fears about dipping into the imaginary Social Security "trust fund," but it's hard to fault the networks for making such a big deal about the sacrosanct "trust fund" when both parties play the game of pretending it exists and promising to protect it. Gibson, however, went a bit far in describing the administration's discovery of a relatively piddling $4.3 billion as "a budget bombshell."
CBS's John Roberts recalled Bush's promise to not spend Social Security money, then let Ari Fleischer defend the new allocation before he referred to the "huge tax cut" as he passed along the Democratic spin: "But Democrats, who had hammered the President for jeopardizing the surplus with his huge tax cut, today denounced the change as an unprecedented accounting gimmick meant to rescue Mr. Bush from a political embarrassment."
In relaying the liberal spin blaming the tax cut, neither ABC or CBS, nor CNN's Major Garrett on Inside Politics, pointed out, as did FNC's Jim Angle, that the majority of the income tax revenue reduction this year was caused by the rebate checks -- an idea championed by Democrats such as Tom Daschle. And neither ABC or CBS raised the point that the tax cut is helping the economy rebound so there will be increased revenue next year.
The NBC Nightly News and MSNBC's The News with Brian Williams didn't touch the subject on Thursday night.
More about the August 16 stories on the ABC and CBS evening shows:
-- ABC's World News Tonight. Anchor Charles Gibson announced: "In Washington today there was something of a budget bombshell and it's of interest to everyone in the country who pays taxes. The Bush administration says it has found $4.3 billion of your money in the federal budget that wasn't there before. The administration says it comes from using a different accounting system. ABC's John Cochran is with the President in Crawford, Texas and John the Democrats are screaming that it's not new accounting, that the Republicans have dipped into the Social Security money."
Cochran provided the Bush team's retort:
"Well Charlie, the counter-argument from the Bush White House is that
past Presidents, including Republican Presidents, have used the wrong
accounting system, that under their system the money would have been
credited erroneously to the Social Security trust fund. Instead the money
can now be used for tax cuts and spending and Charlie, it's money the
Bush administration really needs."
-- CBS Evening News. Anchor Bob Schieffer set
up the story by emphasizing the impact of the economic slowdown:
Roberts explained, as transcribed by MRC
analyst Brad Wilmouth: "Not six months ago, Congress was rolling in
record revenues wondering what to do with all that money. The question
now: Where did it all go? In January, the surplus, excluding extra monies
from Social Security, was pegged at $125 billion. Since then, $74 billion
went to the tax cut, the economic slowdown took out $40 billion more.
What's left is precious little to meet spending priorities without
busting the budget and plunging into the Social Security surplus for the
first time in three years."
Ammunition the networks will be pleased to fire if the Democratic spin blames the tax cut.
If new CNN CEO Walter Isaacson is still wondering why conservatives think CNN is biased to the left, he should cue up a tape of Thursday's Inside Politics in which Bill Schneider fawned over Bill "Elvis" Clinton. With the anniversary of the death of Elvis and Bill Clinton's birthday just three days apart, CNN's John King offered a bit of a stretch as the network celebrated the "mid-August convergence" of the two dates.
"Elvis, the first rock star. Clinton, the first rock star President," Bill Schneider gushed as he began his piece. Schneider soon outlined other parallels: "Clinton had a talent for convincing anyone listening to him that he was speaking only to them, just as Elvis convinced someone in the 100th row that he was singing only to them. Presley drew on black culture for inspiration. Clinton draws on black culture for solace."
Schneider fondly recalled how in 1992 Clinton "used Elvis to demonstrate that he had the common touch, and Bush didn't." He concluded that like Elvis, Clinton "has found life after political death" as he's "trying to do good: Fight AIDS and racism. Clinton is now a free man, a pure celebrity, being paid record amounts of money to tell his story. At long last, Clinton can be Elvis."
Fill-in Inside Politics anchor John King set up the slow news day report with a reach for a connection between two anniversaries: "Now, the story you've all been waiting for, the Elvis Presley-Bill Clinton connection. Today is the 24th anniversary of the death of the King of Rock and Roll. And three days from now, the former President of the United States celebrates his 55th birthday. That mid-August convergence was enough to get our Bill Schneider all shook up."
Schneider began: "John, Bill Clinton,
Elvis Presley: brothers under the skin. Elvis, the first rock star.
Clinton, the first rock star President. It's no secret that Bill Clinton
drew on Elvis for inspiration. You might say Elvis won the 1992 election
Schneider, back on live with King on the DC
roof from which Inside Politics broadcast: "Clinton, too, has found
life after political death. And he's trying to do good: Fight AIDS and
racism. Clinton is now a free man, a pure celebrity, being paid record
amounts of money to tell his story. At long last, Clinton can be Elvis.
[imitating Elvis] Thank you, thank you very much.
King: "Not quite."
And no one else could quite be inspired like CNN's Schneider to pay such tribute to Bill Clinton based upon such a flimsy link to Elvis.
Okay, not no one else but Schneider. How about no one else but the liberal media in general as Schneider may have been inspired by a Monday New York Times story which proclaimed: "Mr. Clinton's Southern-style charisma evokes comparisons with Elvis."
That line appeared in an August 13 Times
profile of Robert Gottlieb, the editor who will handle Bill Clinton's
book. Reporter David D. Kirkpatrick admired Clinton's life story,
Kirkpatrick used the Elvis analogy in
contrasting Gottlieb with Clinton:
If you are registered with the online version
of the New York Times, you can read the entire story by going to:
Eleanor Clift held up a California Democratic Congressman with a solid pro-abortion voting record as "an unlikely champion for expanded stem-cell research."
MRC analyst Ken Shepherd noticed that in her latest "Capitol Letter" column for Newsweek's Web site, Clift baldly asserted that the liberal is an "unlikely champion" of full federal funding for stem cell research that would destroy human embryos. But, as the MRC's Rich Noyes discovered, the California Congressman's voting record shows his support for taxpayer-funded abortions and even late-term abortions.
Here's how Clift started her column posted this week: "Cal Dooley is an unlikely champion for expanded stem-cell research. But Representative Dooley is a Democrat who represents a heavily Hispanic and Catholic district in California's Central Valley. Among California Democrats, only Gary Condit has a more conservative voting record. Yet Dooley was one of the first members of Congress to react strongly against President Bush's decision on limited federal funding for embryonic stem-cell research. Dooley pointed out the missing link in Bush's decision, and that is the fate of the estimated 150,000 embryos currently languishing in fertility-clinic storage tanks around the country."
Nearly as conservative as Condit? According the American Conservative Union, Condit is indeed the least liberal Democrat in California's delegation, with a 48 percent lifetime rating. But runner-up Dooley only scored a 16 percent positive rating from the ACU, making him a pretty orthodox Democrat. And on the two votes that mattered to pro-lifers in the last Congress -- on partial birth abortion and taxpayer funded abortions, Dooley voted a straight-NARAL ticket.
Indeed, in 2000 Dooley earned a perfect 100 percent score from the National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League (NARAL) and a zero from the National Right to Life Committee (NRLC).
So much for Clift's pretense that he's "an unlikely champion for expanded stem-cell research."
To read the remainder of what Clift had to say, go to: http://www.msnbc.com/news/614997.asp
To check Dooley's vote ratings:
For the ACU:
For the NRLC, which only offers them in a PDF
Each has a link to a page describing the specific votes the group evaluated.
The New York Times on Wednesday blamed "a Republican-backed law" for making it too easy for the INS to deport illegal immigrants, even those in fear for their life back home. But as Andrew Sullivan pointed out on his Web site, the law in question passed with overwhelming bipartisan majorities in the House and Senate and was signed by President Clinton.
On Special Report with Brit Hume on Thursday
night FNC's Hume picked up on Sullivan's item. Sullivan, the former
Editor of the New Republic, recounted in an August 15 posting:
The Times story by Eric Schmitt, headlined,
"When Asylum Requests Are Overlooked," began from Texas:
To read the rest of the New York Times story, go to: http://www.nytimes.com/2001/08/15/national/15IMMI.html
For Sullivan's Web page: http://www.andrewsullivan.com/
"Conservatives Use Floggings As Way to Beat Back Reforms" declared a Thursday Washington Post headline. FNC's Brit Hume concluded his August 16 program by showing a shot of the headline, which he introduced by noting: "You've no doubt heard the accusations that big eastern newspapers, such as the Washington Post, have a liberal bias. And what better example than this headline in Thursday's editions of the Washington Post."
Alas, as Hume added, that was the jump page headline. The story wasn't about Tom DeLay. The Post's front page headline announced: "Iran's Cultural Backlash." The subhead: "Public Floggings Used as Tool Against Reform."
Interesting how no matter what the particular situation or nation, to the U.S. news media the bad guys are always labeled "conservative."-- Brent Baker
Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions
which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible
donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert
readers and subscribers:
>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a
blank e-mail to:
>>>You can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: firstname.lastname@example.org. Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.<<<