Conventions 2000: Media Reality Check, Friday AM Edition
1) "Presidential" Bush Won Over Media, But...; "I'll Tell You the Surprise, I Thought It Was a Very Good Speech." Cokie Roberts: "To talk about tearing down the wall between poverty and wealth in America, something you're not used to hearing at a Republican convention." NBC: How can he "afford" tax cuts "for the rich"?
2) ABC & CBS Run Own Bush Bios: "1st in Capital Punishment, 2nd in the Number of Uninsured Children." Bill Whitaker: "Is George W. Bush prepared to lead the most powerful nation on earth? A question compounded when he failed a reporter's pop quiz at the start of the campaign."
4) "Compassion...Obscures the Conservative"; CBS: Cheney" Rigid-Right" But Kerry Just "Liberal." Thursday's CBS Evening News reflected the liberal view that conservative political positions contradict compassion.
5) Sidebar articles along the sides of pages two and three: Rather's Parting Shot: Convention "Excess"; "Cheney Attack Speech"; D-PA vs. R-PA: Brit Hume noted how GOP showcased abortion dissenter; Letterman's GOP Top Ten: "Top Ten Announcements that Would Cause a Panic at the Republican National Convention."
Front page article. "Presidential" Bush Won Over Media, But...; "I'll Tell You the Surprise, I Thought It Was a Very Good Speech"
George W. Bush earned rave reviews Thursday night for his speech, though some were most impressed with its un-Republican aspects and NBC trotted out the usual liberal mantra about paying for tax cuts.
ABC's Cokie Roberts: "I think a very successful speech. Anybody seeing at the beginning George W. Bush's parents watching their child stand up there and accept the nomination was bound to be moved. Even my colleagues here in the press felt that way.....And I think that his echoing that Reagan line of 'tear down this wall,' from Berlin, to talk about tearing down the wall between poverty and wealth in America, something you're not used to hearing at a Republican convention."
CBS's Bob Schieffer: "Well, I'll tell you the surprise, I thought it was a very good speech. I'm not sure I've ever heard George Bush deliver a speech in quite the way he did this one tonight. I thought he struck just the right tone. It was very presidential. No real cheap shots in it, but some very good lines."
CNN's Jeff Greenfield: "The most surprising part of this speech, one I must say I would not have expected necessarily in a Republican convention, was his expression of empathy and sympathy for a 15-year-old juvenile felon."
NBC's Tom Brokaw: "This speech, it seemed to me was a pretty skillful weaving of campaign hot buttons, and a higher calling." Tim Russert agreed, with a caveat: "It was an extremely well written speech. George W. Bush tonight was politician, preacher. But I think Democrats, Republicans, independents would acknowledge he was presidential. There is no doubt about that in terms of stepping up and giving an outline, a vision of where he wants to lead the country....He'll have to explain how he can afford to reform or privatize part of Social Security and still afford tax cuts."
A half hour later on MSNBC Jim Miklaszewski demanded of Phil Gramm: "He left himself wide open on one particular issue when he talked about tax breaks or tax cuts for every tax bracket. Nobody should pay more than one third of their income. Doesn't that translate into tax breaks for the rich?"
Top of page two story. ABC & CBS Run Own Bush Bios: "1st in Capital Punishment, 2nd in the Number of Uninsured Children"
While CNN, FNC, NBC/MSNBC and PBS carried the RNC's Bush biography film, ABC and CBS instead showed viewers their own take. Both raised questions about his military service, stressed the plight of the poor in Texas and resurrected the foreign leader pop quiz.
ABC's Dean Reynolds suggested his lack of interest in a liberal cause demonstrated his lack of leadership abilities: "But is he all handshake and not much else? The same people who recall the friendliness can point to little in the way of leadership qualities they perceived. For example, the 1960s were a turbulent time at Yale. Rebellion and anti-war sentiment were palpable. To many perhaps, but not to Bush." Reynolds soon added: "What about his military obligation in the Texas Air National Guard? He says he fulfilled it, but is hazy in his recollections."
Reynolds soon got to the infamous pop quiz, showing Bush unable to name the President of Chechnya or Prime Minister of India.
Over on CBS, Bill Whitaker asked: "Did his father pull strings to get him a coveted spot with the Texas National Guard while less fortunate sons of Texas went off to Vietnam?" Whitaker asserted: "Though Texas air is some of the dirtiest in the country, he allows polluters to voluntarily comply with environmental regulations. Texas is first in capital punishment, second in the number of uninsured children.....But the Texas constitution grants the Governor limited power, which raises the question is George W. Bush prepared to lead the most powerful nation on earth? A question compounded when he failed a reporter's pop quiz at the start of the campaign."
Bottom of page two article. GOP Crossed the Line from Inclusion to Pandering
ABC's Peter Jennings asked Michel Martin if the GOP crossed the line between inclusion and pandering. Martin, who is black, disqualified Republicans: "I'm not sure that the floor of this convention is the place to ask that question because, I mean, Peter, look around. I mean, the fact of the matter is that....the delegations all over the country are still predominantly Caucasian..."
Jennings wondered Thursday night if Martin's friends and colleagues "think that there's been an overreaching this week?" Martin's friends are not impressed with the GOP: "In my unscientific survey of friends, family that I've been talking to, some people really do think that they've crossed the line."
Just before midnight on CNN, Bruce Morton contended conservative views contradict inclusion: "But inclusion is not universal here. On Powell's affirmative action, the GOP platform says 'we will attain equal opportunity without quotas or other forms of preferential treatment.' The platform would ban all abortions, going further than Bush. It opposes sex education in schools except for teaching abstinence and it opposes laws protecting homosexuals from discrimination....For all the black faces on the podium, how inclusive was this convention? The Joint Center for Political Studies, a Washington think tank, says 4.1 percent of the delegates here were black, up from 1996, but about the same as in 1992 when Pat Buchanan made that cultural war speech."
Page three story. "Compassion...Obscures the Conservative"; CBS: Cheney "Rigid-Right" But Kerry Just "Liberal"
In airing a story about how Bush's "compassion" image "often obscures the conservative" Bush really is, followed by a piece on Gore's potential VP options, Thursday's CBS Evening News not only reflected the liberal view that conservative political positions contradict compassion, but also displayed a double standard on labeling.
-- Bush's Compassion vs. Conservative Reality. Previewing Bush's speech, reporter Bill Whitaker noted: "Staffers say he'll make the compassionate conservative case for change he's stressed for months." Viewers saw a clip of Bush: "I'm not running just to say I've held the office. I'm running because I want to lead this country to a more generous day, a more hospitable day for everybody." Whitaker then adopted the liberal line, countering: "It's a feel-good message with something for everybody. The compassion often obscures the conservative, but it's there. When Dick Cheney's rigid-right congressional votes came under attack, Bush embraced the man and his record."
Whitaker listed Bush's supposed areas of conflict: "He's a master of mixed signals. He refused to challenge this platform's call for a total abortion ban, yet he insists he'd allow them for rape and incest. With diversity [video of J.C. Watts] hogging the spotlight here, hardline conservatives are almost invisible, but when former Christian Coalition head Ralph Reed endorsed Bush he told CBS News the conservative agenda hadn't changed, just the style....Bush says there should be no confusion. He's both compassionate and conservative."
-- VP Labeling Contrast. The networks, especially CBS, haven't hesitated to go beyond just "conservative" and have burdened Dick Cheney with labels which paint him as an extremist, such as "hardline conservative," "far right," and "hard right." So if Al Gore picks Senator John Kerry as his running mate will CBS apply matching tags, such as "hardline liberal" and "hard left"? After all, while Cheney earned a lifetime 91 percent rating from the American Conservative Union, Kerry has a 93 percent lifetime approval rating from the liberal Americans for Democratic Action.
Thursday night CBS demonstrated its bias. A few minutes after Whitaker referred to "Dick Cheney's rigid-right congressional votes," reporter John Roberts looked at how Gore's VP list is "down to four so-called 'new generation' candidates," Senators Evan Bayh, John Kerry, John Edwards and Joe Lieberman. But though Kerry is as liberal as Cheney is conservative, Roberts could only muster the "liberal" label: "What Gore hopes to do is avoid the potshots that the Bush campaign took over George W.'s pick of Dick Cheney for running mate. Bayh is a former Governor of a state that usually votes Republican, but his vote to ban late-term abortion has angered women's groups. Kerry is a Vietnam vet with three purple hearts, but he's a liberal from a state Gore should already win..."
It's the media which took the "potshots" at Cheney and the media which will decide whether to take them at Gore's pick.
Sidebar articles along the sides of pages two and three: Rather's Parting Shot: Convention "Excess"; "Cheney Attack Speech"; D-PA vs. R-PA: Brit Hume noted how GOP showcased abortion dissenter; Letterman's GOP Top Ten: "Top Ten Announcements that Would Cause a Panic at the Republican National Convention."
Rather's Parting Shot: Convention "Excess" Dan Rather signed off CBS's coverage at 11:10 pm ET with this pontificating: "When the Founding Fathers met in this city in the late 1700s and wrote the rules for electing the President they could not have foreseen what we have seen here this week and what we will pretty much see again when the Democrats convene in Los Angeles. The process has gone from James Madison to Madison Avenue. Conventions are now political marketing operations, all about big money, power and influence. Just over 200 years ago another George W., George Washing-ton, left Philadelphia after two terms as President. In his farewell address Washington warned about the excesses of political parties. He was not talking about conventions, but he could have been."
"Cheney Attack Speech"
Dan Rather introduced a CBS Evening News preview of Bush's speech: "It is an opportunity for Bush to define his vision of where he would take the country and say why he should be the one to lead it. The context includes the Dick Cheney attack speech here last night on the Democrats."
D-PA vs. R-PA
Letterman's GOP Top Ten From the August 2 Late Show with David Letterman, the "Top Ten Announcements that Would Cause a Panic at the Republican National Convention."
10. "Stop by the concession area and pick up Barbara Bush's
END Reprints of Media Reality Check articles
This "Conventions 2000: Media Reality
Check" compiled by me
Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions
which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible
donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert
readers and subscribers:
>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a
blank e-mail to:
>>>You can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: email@example.com. Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.