Post Drills Holes in Arguments Against Offshore Oil
It‚Äôs not often that you can point to The Washington Post as the voice of reason, but the paper has its moments. One such was the August 12 oil drilling editorial that debunks three major ‚Äú‚Äėtruths‚Äô masquerading as fact‚ÄĚ about offshore drilling.
The piece, headlined ‚ÄúSnake Oil,‚ÄĚ showed how groups like the Natural Resources Defense Council misrepresent the reality of offshore drilling by downplaying the amount of oil, claiming existing leases are going unused and maximizing the ‚Äúdanger.‚ÄĚ The NRDC, a $75-million liberal environmental group, had taken out ads in the Post and other papers detailing its opposition to drilling.
While the editorial argued against drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) because it ‚Äúshould be preserved,‚ÄĚ the Post went on to explain why drilling offshore makes sense.
‚ÄúThe NRDC's arguments above neatly encapsulate the position taken by environmentalists and other opponents of offshore drilling,‚ÄĚ wrote the editorial.
So here are the three arguments the Post neatly dissects:
¬∑ Drilling is pointless because the
¬∑ The oil companies aren't using the leases they already have.
¬∑ Drilling is environmentally dangerous.
Reality, even the Post‚Äôs reality, is far different.
The paper explained how the estimates of 18 billion barrels of oil offshore are based on old measurements. Data from the Interior Department's Minerals Management Service (MMS) are out of date. In a similar situation, the Post wrote, the department estimated 9 billion barrels were
That‚Äôs a 400-percent increase. A similar rise would mean 90 billion barrels of oil are offshore.
The Post also disregarded the claim that oil companies don‚Äôt use the leases they now own. ‚ÄúThe notion that oil companies are just sitting on oil leases is a myth. With oil prices still above $100 a barrel, that charge never made sense,‚ÄĚ the paper wrote.
To tackle the claim that drilling offshore is bad for the environment, the Post went back to the MMS. ‚ÄúAccording to the MMS, between 1993 and 2007, there were 651 spills of all sizes at OCS facilities (in federal waters three miles or more offshore) that released 47,800 barrels of oil. With 7.5 billion barrels of oil produced in that time, that equates to 1 barrel of oil spilled per 156,900 barrels produced.‚ÄĚ
‚ÄúBesides,‚ÄĚ went the editorial, ‚Äúif it is acceptable to drill in the Caspian Sea and in developing countries such as