Appearance Alert!
MRC's Brent Bozell on FNC's The Kelly File, Friday 9:40pm ET/PT

The New York Times Laments Disappearance of Moderate Republicans (Again, and Again)

The Times rehashes a lament that goes back at least 14 years: "The few remaining Republican centrists in the Senate were eagerly awaiting the arrival of Michael N. Castle of Delaware, a longtime and reliable moderate voice who could provide some counterbalance to the wave of conservatives poised to enter Congress and the steadily rightward shift of party leaders."

Reporters David Herszenhorn and Carl Hulse pondered the hazards the Tea Party poses for "the few remaining Republican centrists in the Senate," those brave politicians "who are not lock-step conservatives," in Monday's "Tea Party Victory Opens Rift Between Moderate and Conservative Republicans." It's the same article the Times has been running for over a decade.

The few remaining Republican centrists in the Senate were eagerly awaiting the arrival of Michael N. Castle of Delaware, a longtime and reliable moderate voice who could provide some counterbalance to the wave of conservatives poised to enter Congress and the steadily rightward shift of party leaders.

But Mr. Castle was defeated in his party primary on Tuesday by Christine O'Donnell, a Tea Party insurgent. And while the conservative wing rejoiced, the surprise outcome raised serious questions about the future place in the party of lawmakers like Senators Olympia J. Snowe and Susan Collins of Maine and other Republicans in the Senate and House who are not lock-step conservatives.

Senator Jim DeMint, the South Carolina Republican who has seen his stature rise through his support of conservative candidates, made it clear in the aftermath of the Delaware upset that he would prefer losing a seat to Democrats than having Republican colleagues who stray from the conservative line and erode party unity and image by voting for policies supported by the Obama administration.

The ascendancy of the right is forcing even some of the most loyal Republicans, like Senator Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, the No. 3 Senate Republican, to defend their conservative bona fides. And it seems to be dashing the hopes among moderates that the prospect of winning a majority in the House, and a pursuit of independent voters, would push Republican leaders to the middle.


Crying over "the few remaining Republican centrists" (the disappearance of centrist Democrats is for some reason never seen as a problem) is a long-running theme in the Times. Times reporter Adam Clymer wrote of the "dwindling band of Republican moderates." The date? December 1, 1996. Strangely, although these embattled pols have been disappearing for at least 14 years, a remnant is still always at hand to be the sympathetic subject of yet another Times article lamenting their disappearance.

The Times already misses moderate Mike Castle, evidently a modern-day Abe Lincoln of integrity:

And while other Republicans with moderate credentials, including Representative Mark Steven Kirk of Illinois, still have a good chance of winning in November, none would arrive in the Senate with the moderate stamp and stature of Mr. Castle, who has served in the House for 18 years, and is both well-known and respected in both parties.

You can follow Times Watch on Twitter.